Explainer New
In a 2026 marketplace fees comparison on a typical $35 sale, eBay and Amazon take the biggest cut at roughly 15–16% each. Etsy takes about 11% before ads, and Shopify about 5% plus its monthly plan. Shopify’s low fees come with a catch, though: you pay for all your own traffic. Once ads and fulfillment are counted, the cheapest channel depends on your product and how buyers find you.
On this page
- Why Headline Fee Rates Mislead
- Amazon Seller Fees in 2026
- eBay Seller Fees in 2026
- Etsy Seller Fees in 2026
- Shopify Fees in 2026
- Marketplace Fees Comparison: The Same $35 Order on Every Platform
- Which Platform Is Cheapest for Your Products?
- The Real Cost of Selling on Multiple Channels
- How to Run Your Own Comparison
- The Bottom Line
Ask ten sellers which platform has the lowest fees and you’ll hear ten answers. Some will say Shopify, because the percentages are tiny. Others will say Etsy, because there’s no monthly fee. A few will defend eBay or Amazon because those platforms bring the most buyers.
They’re all partly right, which is why a proper marketplace fees comparison has to go beyond headline rates. This guide puts Amazon, eBay, Etsy and Shopify side by side using 2026 rates, runs the same $35 order through each, and then adds the costs most comparisons skip: fulfillment, advertising, and the work of selling on several channels at once.
Why Headline Fee Rates Mislead
Each platform charges in a different way:
- Amazon takes a referral fee on each sale, plus a monthly plan and optional FBA fulfillment fees.
- eBay takes a final value fee on the total sale, including shipping and tax, plus a per-order fee.
- Etsy combines a listing fee, a transaction fee and payment processing, with Offsite Ads charged on some orders.
- Shopify charges a monthly plan and card processing, but brings no marketplace traffic at all.
Comparing “15% vs 13.6% vs 6.5% vs 2.9%” is comparing different things. The only fair test is to run the same order through each platform and add up everything.
Amazon Seller Fees in 2026
Amazon charges professional sellers $39.99 a month, or $0.99 per item sold on the Individual plan. The main cost is the referral fee, which in most categories is 15% of the sale price, including any shipping you charge. Some categories are lower (around 8%), and a few are higher.
If Amazon ships the order through FBA, you also pay a fulfillment fee based on size, weight and price band. 2026 brought several changes here, including price-based FBA fees and a 3.5% fuel surcharge. They’re all covered in our breakdown of Amazon FBA fees in 2026.
Official rates are on Amazon’s selling pricing page. To check a specific product, the free Amazon fee calculator splits a sale into referral fees, fulfillment and proceeds.
eBay Seller Fees in 2026
eBay has no required monthly fee. Instead, it takes a final value fee of 13.6% in most categories, charged on the total sale, including shipping and sales tax, plus $0.40 per order over $10 ($0.30 on smaller orders).
Category rates vary widely. Guitars pay 6.7%, authenticated sneakers over $150 pay 8%, and books and media pay 15.3%. A Basic Store or higher drops most categories to 12.7%. Promoted Listings, a 1.65% international fee and a Below Standard surcharge can all push the cost higher.
Our guide to eBay fees 2026 by category has the full table. You can run any listing through the eBay fee calculator.
Etsy Seller Fees in 2026
Etsy has three core fees for US sellers:
- $0.20 listing fee, renewing every four months and on each sale
- 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus shipping
- 3% + $0.25 payment processing on the order total, including tax
That usually comes to about 11% of an order. The big variable is Offsite Ads: if a buyer comes through an Etsy-placed ad, you pay another 15% (or 12% once your shop passes $10,000 a year), capped at $100 per order. Sellers in some countries also pay regulatory operating fees, which changed in June 2026.
Our full Etsy fees 2026 breakdown covers every line. The Etsy fee calculator handles the math for any listing.
Shopify Fees in 2026
Shopify isn’t a marketplace. It’s software for running your own store. That’s why its fees look so low:
- Plans: Basic $39/month ($29 billed yearly), Grow $105/month ($79 yearly), Advanced $399/month
- Card processing with Shopify Payments: 2.9% + 30¢ on Basic, dropping to about 2.5% + 30¢ on Advanced
- Third-party payment gateways: an extra Shopify fee of roughly 0.6–2% depending on plan, plus the gateway’s own rate
- Apps and themes: often $20–$200+ a month for a working store
Check Shopify’s pricing page for current plan details. The real cost of Shopify is traffic. Nobody finds your store unless you bring them there through ads, SEO, email or social media. The Shopify profit calculator includes apps, shipping and ad spend, so you can see the full cost.
Marketplace Fees Comparison: The Same $35 Order on Every Platform
Here’s one order: a $35 product (shipping included in the price), $2.45 sales tax where it affects fees, and about 200 orders a month, so monthly plans can be spread per order.
| Fee | Amazon | eBay | Etsy | Shopify (Basic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main selling fee | 15% referral: $5.25 | 13.6% of $37.45: $5.09 | 6.5% transaction: $2.28 | — |
| Payment processing | Included | Included | 3% + $0.25: $1.37 | 2.9% + 30¢: $1.39 |
| Fixed per-order/listing fee | — | $0.40 | $0.20 | — |
| Monthly plan per order | $0.20 | — | — | $0.20 |
| Apps (est. $50/mo) | — | — | — | $0.25 |
| Total platform fees | $5.45 | $5.49 | $3.85 | $1.84 |
| Share of $35 | 15.6% | 15.7% | 11.0% | 5.3% |
On platform fees alone, eBay and Amazon take the biggest cut, almost tied at about 15.5%. Etsy is in the middle, and Shopify looks cheapest by a wide margin.
Add Each Platform’s Advertising
Few sellers get every sale without ads. Here’s how that changes the picture:
- Etsy with Offsite Ads (15%): +$5.25, for $9.10 total (26%)
- eBay with 5% Promoted Listings: +about $1.87, for $7.36 total (21%)
- Amazon PPC: depends on your ACoS. At a 25% ACoS on half your orders, it adds about $4.38 per order on average. Our guide to what a good ACoS on Amazon is explains how to set it.
- Shopify: every order comes from traffic you paid for or built yourself. If you spend $6 in ads per order, the total becomes $7.84 (22.4%). At $10 per order, it’s $11.84 (33.8%).
So which channel takes the biggest cut? It depends on how much of your traffic you have to buy.
Add Fulfillment
Shipping changes the comparison too. On eBay, Etsy, Shopify and Amazon FBM, you pay to pick, pack and ship yourself. Say that’s $6 per order. With Amazon FBA, the fulfillment fee replaces it: about $3.91 for a 12–16 oz large-standard item, including the fuel surcharge. You’ll also pay storage, inbound freight and prep.
| Fees + fulfillment (no ads) | Amazon FBA | eBay | Etsy | Shopify |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platform fees | $5.45 | $5.49 | $3.85 | $1.84 |
| Fulfillment | $3.91 FBA + ~$0.65 storage & inbound | $6.00 | $6.00 | $6.00 |
| Total | $10.01 (28.6%) | $11.49 (32.8%) | $9.85 (28.1%) | $7.84 (22.4%) |
Once fulfillment is included, Amazon, Etsy and Shopify end up much closer than the headline rates suggest, and eBay becomes the most expensive for this product.
Which Platform Is Cheapest for Your Products?
There isn’t one cheapest platform to sell on. Here’s how it usually works out:
- Handmade, vintage and craft items: Etsy’s fees are moderate, and its buyers are looking for exactly that. Keep an eye on Offsite Ads.
- Used, collectible and niche items: eBay’s reach for secondhand goods is hard to beat, and some categories, like guitars and premium sneakers, have unusually low rates.
- Branded or private-label products with demand: Amazon’s traffic and FBA can be worth 15%, especially once you count fulfillment.
- Products with an existing audience: Shopify’s low fees work best when you already have email lists, social followers or organic search traffic.
- Low-priced items: watch fixed fees everywhere. eBay’s $0.30–$0.40 per order, Etsy’s $0.45, and Shopify’s 30¢ all hurt more on a $10 item than on a $50 one. Bundling helps on every platform.
Category rates can flip the ranking completely. An eBay guitar seller pays 6.7%, while an eBay book seller pays 15.3%. Always compare for your real category, not the “most categories” rate.
Hidden Costs That Fee Comparisons Miss
The fee lines are only part of what each platform costs. Here’s what else to compare:
- Returns: each platform has different return policies and costs, and returns cut into every margin above. Our guide to managing returns across marketplaces covers how to handle them.
- Account health penalties: eBay’s Below Standard surcharge and Amazon’s account metrics both punish late shipments and cancellations.
- Payout timing: each platform holds and releases money on its own schedule, which affects cash flow.
- Bookkeeping time: four platforms means four fee reports in four formats.
The Real Cost of Selling on Multiple Channels
Most sellers who grow past a certain size don’t choose one platform. They sell on two or three, each matched to the products and buyers it serves best. A marketplace fees comparison helps you decide what to sell where. Running several channels at once brings its own costs, though.
Overselling. When the same stock is listed on Amazon, eBay, Etsy and Shopify, every sale has to update every other channel right away. If it doesn’t, you’ll sell items you no longer have, cancel orders and hurt your seller metrics, which can raise your fees on eBay. Keeping stock synced across all your accounts in one place prevents this. Our guides to automating inventory updates across channels and managing Shopify and Amazon inventory together show how.
Pricing per channel. With fees ranging from about 5% to over 25%, the same price everywhere means different margins everywhere. Many sellers price slightly higher on high-fee channels to keep profit consistent. A marketplace profitability analysis shows which channel actually earns the most per product.
Reconciling payouts. Each platform deducts its fees before paying you, on different schedules and in different formats. Our guides to marketplace payout reconciliation and multichannel ecommerce bookkeeping cover a monthly routine that keeps it manageable.
For a broader look at running several channels well, see our multi-channel ecommerce guide.
How to Run Your Own Comparison
- Pick your top five products. Use real prices, weights and categories.
- Run each one through every platform’s calculator. Use the Amazon, eBay and Etsy fee calculators, and the Shopify profit calculator.
- Add fulfillment and ad costs per channel, using your actual numbers.
- Compare profit per order, not fee percentage. That’s the number that matters.
- Repeat every quarter. All four platforms changed fees in 2026, and they’ll change again.
The Bottom Line
A fair marketplace fees comparison shows that no platform simply has the lowest fees. On a typical $35 sale, eBay and Amazon take about 15–16%, Etsy about 11% (or around a quarter with Offsite Ads), and Shopify about 5% plus whatever you spend on traffic. Once fulfillment and advertising are included, the gaps shrink, and sometimes the ranking flips.
The sellers who come out ahead don’t look for one cheap platform. They put each product where it earns the most and manage stock, orders and payouts across every account from one place. Your next step: run your five best-selling products through each fee calculator, and see which channel actually gives you the best profit per order.
FAQ
Questions about this
See it running on your orders.
Book a 20-minute walk-through with the RASCODEX team, or start the 7-day free trial.
Request a Demo WhatsApp Us
Comments
No comments yet.